|2012||Jarret Eaton||Erik van Ingen||Robert Golabek|
|Syracuse U, Syracuse, NY||Binghamton U, Binghamton, NY||University at Buffalo, Buffalo, NY|
|Abington, PA / Abington HS||Marathon, NY / Marathon HS||Hamburg, NY / Hamburg HS|
|2013||Jonathan Jones||Stephen Mozia||Donald Pollitt|
|University at Buffalo, Buffalo, NY||Cornell University||Syracuse University|
|Portville, NY / Portville HS||Hackensack, NJ / Hackensack HS||Hazelton, PA / Hazelton Area HS|
Presented annually by the Niagara Track & Field Hall of Fame to the outstanding NCAA Division 1 College Male Athlete of the Year in or from the Niagara Association.
This award is named for Donald J. Paige, a member of the Hall of Fame's Class of 2000, who graduated from C.W. Baker High School, Baldwinsville, NY, and Villanova University. He was a member of the 1980 United States Olympic Track and Field Team for 800 meters, and was Pan-American Games Champion at 1500 meters in 1979. He set five World Records, two American Records, and one Collegiate Best. Paige is a Two-time USA National Champion Indoors at 1,000 yards and a six-time NCAA Champion.